Alex T’s Top 10 Pizza Spots in MoCo

'
October 13, 2020
MCS Staff

Alex T’s Top 10 MoCo Pizza Spots

 

We sat down with Alex T, the founder of The MoCoShow, to ask him about his Top 10 MoCo pizza spots.

 

If you’ve heard him on the podcast, he has plenty to say about pizza, and was more than excited to share his personal favorites. He has tried the pizza at over 75 different MoCo establishments in the last 4 years and has documented every experience.

 

“I don’t care if you’re Gordon Ramsay. It doesn’t matter if you’re originally from New York or New Jersey…or if you’ve been to Italy 17 times. Your opinion is just that…your opinion.” Alex said, while explaining that everyone’s list is going to be different.

 

He added that he’s personally not a fan of brick oven or Neapolitan style pizza. So if that’s your thing…this list probably isn’t for you (this one might be)

 

Note: Places like Ledo Pizza and other national chains are not eligible for his list of pizza spots that are more exclusive to MoCo than outside of it.

 

Just Missed: Maggi’s Pizza (Damascus), Broadway (Potomac), Corner Slice (Bethesda), Vace (Bethesda), Slice of Rockville (Rockville)

 

10. Mamma Lucia (throughout MoCo): “I like it, but I don’t love it. Even though there are plenty of locations across MoCo, It’s not necessarily convenient to where I live, but I do find myself going back for it. That has always been very telling for me.”

 

9. Cuginis (Poolesville): “I’m not in Poolesville much, but every time I’m in the area I have to consider stopping at Cuginis for pizza. It reminds me of Slice of Rockville, which is a solid pizza place, but maybe the fact that it’s not as readily available to me makes me rank it a little higher. Check it out if you’re ever in the area.”

 

8. Mangino’s (Germantown): “It dropped a bit for me since moving out of the gas station. In my head it tastes a little different. Still good, just not as high as I used to have it.”

 

7. Milano’s (Gaithersburg and Germantown): “It’s a delivery spot and most people want to discount it because of that. I’ve found myself ordering Milano’s quite often and have never heard any complaints.”

 

6. CSNY Pizza (Rockville): “This is the closest I’ve had to pizza that I’ve eaten in New York. That doesn’t make it any better or worse, but if you generally enjoy the pizza in NY, this is going to be pretty close.”

 

5. Giuseppi’s (Gaithersburg and Rockville): “I love the pizza, but I’m not a big fan of the crust. It doesn’t have much taste to it and it’s a little too crispy for me. That’s the only thing holding it back.”

 

4. Armand’s (Rockville): “it’s the only one left in the DMV and one of just two left in the whole world. I know it’s not truly Chicago style pizza, but I love it anyway. It can be a little hit or miss, but even when it misses…it’s pretty good.”

 

3. Gentleman Jim’s (Gaithersburg): “This is one of the most polarizing pizzas out there, but in a big fan. You can get it the way it comes (Swiss cheese), or you can ask for provolone if you prefer more of a traditional  approach. They, along with Ledo Pizza and Pizza Oven, are responsible for Maryland Style pizza  from way back when the Cavalier restaurant in DC started doing it (later changed to GJ’s and moved to Twinbrook before coming to Gaithersburg).”

 

2. Continental (Kensington): “Bring your cash go try it. It’s another “Maryland Style” pizza, but this one is a little thicker than the rest (not by much). Very tasty pizza.

 

1. Stained Glass Pub (Glenmont): Most of you knew this was coming. The rectangular Maryland style pizza is the kind I grew up with and their version is by far my favorite. Half price on Mondays and Tuesdays makes it taste even better.
'

14 Comments

  1. Kurt on October 13, 2020 at 5:18 pm

    Nice you learned a bit about GJ Pizza. Stainware’s does make a good pizza. I always note Giuseppi’s crust as chewy, or soft, not at all crunchy but for the edge maybe. Continental is good, subs also and great at washing money. Ledo should be in there, but being an anti-Capitalist blog, understand the exclusion.

  2. Drl on October 13, 2020 at 7:08 pm

    Surprised the author didn’t mention Pizza Hut LOL. If you are looking for REAL Neapolitan style pizza, Cipolla Rossa travelling pizza and Inferno Pizza near QO HS is amazing. But the commentor here earlier is correct, this isn’t pro capitalist to include these.

  3. Steve on October 13, 2020 at 8:45 pm

    Where is Inferno?!?!

    • MCS Staff on October 13, 2020 at 9:52 pm

      It’s Neapolitan style pizza.
      MR

      • Brad R on October 14, 2020 at 11:31 am

        I do love the crust at Giuseppe’s. List is accurate!!! Well done

  4. Jennie on October 13, 2020 at 8:53 pm

    Missed M&N’s in Bethesda!

  5. Susie on October 13, 2020 at 9:45 pm

    Missed so many good places: Pines of Rome, Vace, Pizzeria de Marco, all in Bethesda. All fab.

    • MCS Staff on October 13, 2020 at 9:51 pm

      They weren’t missed, they’re just not on his Top 10 list.

      MR

  6. Mike on October 13, 2020 at 9:56 pm

    I’m in Rockville and Giuseppi’s is the top of my list, but it’s best when given more of an opportunity to crisp up than their standard bake they put on it. There’s so much cheese the parts of the slices from the middle of the pie are just too floppy. If you’re ordering for pickup, ask them to give it a little extra time to crisp it up. It works wonders. Back when I was in high school at RM we’d hit up the original location for the $5 for 2 slices and a drink deal at lunch time. They’d warm already-made slices up in the deck oven which had a similar extra-crispy effect.

    Mamma Lucia’s standard bake doesn’t have the floppy middle-of-the-pizza problem, but just a little less exciting than Giuseppi’s. I like it though.

    Personally I’m not a huge fan of CSNY, the crust is too thin for my taste.

    If only Vince & Dominic’s by Montgomery Mall was still around! Pour one out for that place.

  7. John Majane III on October 14, 2020 at 10:31 am

    Giuseppi’s has the right crust, it is supposed to be thin and crispy. Also they sell by the slice, two pieces more than enough. As close to NYC pizza as you are going to get in the DC area.

  8. Big Bri on October 14, 2020 at 11:19 am

    This list is Trash without Frankly Pizza.

    • MCS Staff on October 14, 2020 at 2:41 pm

      “He added that he’s personally not a fan of brick oven or Neapolitan style pizza. So if that’s your thing…this list probably isn’t for you”

  9. Jayarra on October 14, 2020 at 3:23 pm

    Y’all realize this just one mans opinion right? How you gonna tell him what should be on a list of his favorites? Four Corners up there for me but this good.

  10. Brad Smith on October 15, 2020 at 12:22 pm

    what about Angelo’s pizza? great local pie! very tasty!

Leave a Comment